Feeding
Every product in this category we have reviewed, and where each one stands with us. We don’t sell anything: add the ones you want to a list, then send them all to your Amazon cart or buy each one where it’s sold. In a hurry? The cheat sheet below is the short list.
- Reviewed
- 35
- On a cheat sheet
- 13
- Brands
- 23
★ Start here · the cheat sheet
BPA-free pacifiers and teethers, on one page
A winner for each way people buy it, then what to skip. BPA is out of formula packaging, bottles and sippy cups, but that never covered pacifiers and teethers — that gap is why this page exists.
5 winners1 thing to skip5 of these products are on it
BPA-free pacifiers and teethers cheat sheetthe winner for each cut
- Best overall pacifier
Natursutten 2-Pack Natural Rubber PacifiersNatursutten natural rubber pacifiers — one-piece natural rubber, so there is no plasticizer to ask about. - Undecorated natural rubber teether
Sophie la girafe So'pure Circle TeetherSophie la girafe So'Pure circle teether — natural rubber, undecorated. Two other Sophie toys were recalled in France in 2026; no US recall of this teether found as of October 2026. - Lower price point teether
Nuby Jackie The Giraffe Super Soft Teether Toy for Sore…Nuby Jackie the Giraffe — natural rubber teether at a much lower price point. - Silicone teether (latex allergy in the family)
haakaa Silicone Clover TeetherHaakaa Silicone Clover Teether — silicone, the alternative to natural rubber; the maker declares 100% food-grade silicone and BPA, PVC and phthalate-free. - Silicone pacifier (0-6 months)
Dr. Brown's Advantage One-Piece Silicone Baby PacifierDr. Brown's Advantage One-Piece Silicone Pacifier — soft silicone, declared BPA-free by the maker; silicone is the alternative where there is a latex allergy.
SkipHollow, squeezy bath-toy-style teethers
What to know about feeding
The full guide →Ask what it is made of, not what it is free from. Almost everything a baby feeds from is meant to be soft or unbreakable, and the materials that do those jobs — silicone, natural rubber, TPR, glass, stainless steel — never needed BPA in the first place. A material answer is stable; a marketing claim is only as good as the production run behind it.
Common risks
- Assuming the BPA rules cover pacifiers, teethers or canned food — they do not
- "BPA-free" as the whole answer on a hard, clear plastic item
- Multi-piece designs where a seam can trap milk
What to look for
- One-piece natural rubber, for pacifiers and teethers
- Silicone, where there is a latex allergy
- Glass or stainless steel, for anything that needs to be rigid
- A stated material rather than a "free from" claim
The free change
Ask what it is made of, not what it is free from.
The BPA rules cover baby bottles, sippy cups and infant formula packaging. They did not cover pacifiers and teethers, and they say nothing about groceries.
Brands in this category
23 brands. The ones with a product on a cheat sheet come first.Every brand, A–Z →
35 reviewed safer bottles, cups & feeding products
Cheat sheet winners first- Natursutten 2-Pack Natural Rubber Pacifiers★ Best overall pacifierNatursutten natural rubber pacifiers — one-piece natural rubber, so there is no plasticizer to ask about.Why it won, on the cheat sheet →Amazon
- Sophie la girafe So'pure Circle Teether★ Undecorated natural rubber teetherSophie la girafe So'Pure circle teether — natural rubber, undecorated. Two other Sophie toys were recalled in France in 2026; no US recall of this teether found as of October 2026.Why it won, on the cheat sheet →Amazon
- Nuby Jackie The Giraffe Super Soft Teether Toy for Sore Gums★ Lower price point teetherNuby Jackie the Giraffe — natural rubber teether at a much lower price point.Why it won, on the cheat sheet →Amazon
- haakaa Silicone Clover Teether★ Silicone teether (latex allergy in the family)Haakaa Silicone Clover Teether — silicone, the alternative to natural rubber; the maker declares 100% food-grade silicone and BPA, PVC and phthalate-free.Why it won, on the cheat sheet →Amazon
- Dr. Brown's Advantage One-Piece Silicone Baby Pacifier★ Silicone pacifier (0-6 months)Dr. Brown's Advantage One-Piece Silicone Pacifier — soft silicone, declared BPA-free by the maker; silicone is the alternative where there is a latex allergy.Why it won, on the cheat sheet →Amazon
Earth's Best Organic Baby Formula for Babies 0-12 MonthsOn a cheat sheetOrganic infant formulaAmazon 
Earth's Best · Earths Best, Organic Gentle Infant Formula with Iron Milk Based PowderOn a cheat sheetOrganic infant formulaAmazon 
Happy Baby, Organic Stage 1On a cheat sheetOrganic infant formulaAmazon - Cheat sheetLess-plastic sippy cups, bottles and water bottlesBest no-spill sippy cup: Munchkin Stainless Steel Sippy CupOpen the sheet →
Happy Baby, Organic Stage 1 A2On a cheat sheetOrganic infant formulaAmazon 
Klean Kanteen 12oz Kid's Classic Water Bottle with Flip Seal Sport Cap and StrawOn a cheat sheetLess-plastic sippy cups, bottles and water bottlesAmazon Klean Kanteen site 
Munchkin Cool Cat Toddler Straw CupOn a cheat sheetLess-plastic sippy cups, bottles and water bottlesAmazon 
Munchkin Stainless Steel Sippy CupOn a cheat sheetLess-plastic sippy cups, bottles and water bottlesAmazon 
Re-Play 10 oz Insulated Stainless Steel Sippy CupOn a cheat sheetLess-plastic sippy cups, bottles and water bottlesAmazon 
ezpz Tiny Cup, 4 months+A pick in our guideThe 7 best straw and open cups for your baby's transition off the bottleAmazon 
Klean Kanteen 10oz Kid's Straw CupA pick in our guideStainless Steel Sippy CupsAmazon Klean Kanteen site 
Klean Kanteen 12 oz Classic Kid's Sippy BottleA pick in our guideStainless Steel Sippy CupsAmazon Klean Kanteen site 
Legendairy Milk Honey Bear Straw Cup for Baby & ToddlerA pick in our guideThe 7 best straw and open cups for your baby's transition off the bottleAmazon 
Munchkin C'est Silicone! Open Training Cup with Straw for Babies and Toddlers 6…A pick in our guideThe 7 best straw and open cups for your baby's transition off the bottleAmazon 
mushie 100% Silicone Training Cup & Straw for ToddlersA pick in our guideThe 7 best straw and open cups for your baby's transition off the bottleAmazon 
Olababy Baby Cup, Silicone Open CupA pick in our guideThe 7 best straw and open cups for your baby's transition off the bottleAmazon Olababy site 
Olababy Silicone Straw Training CupA pick in our guideThe 7 best straw and open cups for your baby's transition off the bottleAmazon Olababy site 
WeeSprout Silicone Baby Cups With Straws and LidsA pick in our guideThe 7 best straw and open cups for your baby's transition off the bottleAmazon 
Zak Designs Zaksaurus Kelso 12oz Stainless Steel Leak-Proof Toddler CupA pick in our guideStainless Steel Sippy CupsAmazon 
Béaba Baby Stainless Steel Straw Sippy CupReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
Contigo Kids Stainless Steel Water Bottle with AUTOSPOUT StrawReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
Dapple Refill Pack Baby Bottle and Dish LiquidReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
Dr. Brown's Insulated Stainless Steel Water BottleReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
Jumble Dream Stainless Steel Sippy CupReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
Munchkin® Cool Cat Stainless Steel Toddler Cup with StrawReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.
Nuby Thirsty Kids Flexstraw Stainless Steel Insulated Toddler CupReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
Nuby Thirsty Kids No Spill Flip-It Reflex Stainless Steel Travel Cup or Water B…ReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
Owala Tumbler Kids Stainless Steel Water Bottle 12 oz Lilac RocketReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
Pura Toddler Sippy Cup Straw BottleReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.
THERMOS FUNTAINER Water Bottle with StrawReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon 
THERMOS Kids Stainless Steel Sippy Cup with HandlesReviewedWe looked at it; it is not one of our current picks.Amazon
Feeding: common questions
Is BPA still allowed in baby products?
Not in baby bottles, sippy cups or infant formula packaging — that removal is real and settled. It did not extend to pacifiers and teethers, and it does not touch general groceries.
What should I look for instead of "BPA-free"?
The material. Silicone, natural rubber, TPR, glass and stainless steel answer the question by what they are. A material answer is stable in a way a marketing claim is not.
Natural rubber or silicone for a teether?
One-piece natural rubber is the simplest answer available. Silicone is the right call where there is a latex allergy.