Sourcing safer products for families since 2007
SafeMama
Check home

Non-Toxic Markers: What the AP Seal Covers, Scented Markers, and What We'd Buy

Reviewed by SafeMama editorial · November 15, 2026
4 products rankedAgent researched, editor reviewed

Every marker sold in the US as an art material has to be reviewed by a toxicologist and labeled to a federal standard, so "non-toxic" on the box does not separate one set from another. What does differ is whether a seal can be looked up, whether the maker says what the ink is, whether the marker is scented, and how much mess it makes when a three-year-old gets hold of it. Here is what we could check for Crayola's washable, mess-free and scented lines, and what we could not.

Federal labeling law already requires a toxicologist's review of every art material sold in the US, so the useful questions about markers are narrower: can the seal be looked up, does the maker say what the ink is, is the marker scented, and does it wash off? We searched ACMI's certified-product register in a browser on 2026-11-15 and read Crayola's pages. The register lists Crayola's Ultra-Clean Washable Markers, Color Wonder Markers, Pip-Squeaks Washable Markers and Silly Scents Washable Markers with the AP seal, and Crayola's FAQ says the ink in its markers is "water and dye" (the exact formulas are "proprietary"). Crayola is the only marker maker whose pages we read in full, so this is not a ranking of makers. If you want one set, Crayola's Ultra-Clean Washable Markers are the one we would buy: a seal you can look up, a washability claim the maker makes about skin, clothing and painted walls, and about 35 cents a marker in the 40-count box. We did not test any marker, we did not find a marker maker that names its dyes, and the register does not say whether a scent is more than a fragrance blend, so for scented sets we say plainly what we could not check.

On your shelf: what Crayola's marker lines let you check

Two Crayola marker lines you may already own, checked against ACMI's certified-product search on 2026-11-15 and the maker's own FAQ. The badge asks one question: can you check both what the ink is and whether the seal is real? Green means the maker describes the ink (here, as water and dye) and ACMI's register lists the line with the AP seal; amber means only part of that can be checked. It is a statement about what is checkable, not a safety finding. Every marker here is sold under the same US labeling rules. We did not contact the companies or test any marker.

Crayola Ultra-Clean Washable MarkersInk described (water and dye); AP seal in ACMI's register
Crayola's FAQ says "The basic ingredients in Crayola® Markers are water and dye," and its marker manufacturing FAQ says "specific ingredient information is proprietary" but that most of the ink solutions in its markers are made from water and dyes. ACMI's search lists Crayola Ultra Clean Washable Markers, My First Ultra Clean Washable Markers and the Fineline and Broadline lines with the AP seal. What we could not find: which dyes. "Water and dye" is a category, not an ingredient list, and a proprietary formula is the maker's right under US law; the seal tells you a toxicologist reviewed the formula, not what is in it. Crayola's safety FAQ says all its products "are non-toxic and safe to use"; we read that as the maker's statement. Source (checked )
Crayola Silly Scents scented markersOnly part of that can be checked
ACMI's search has a separate category for scented markers, and lists Crayola Silly Scents Washable Markers, Silly Scents Markers and several Smash Ups lines with the AP seal. Crayola's pages we read say "fun fragrances that kids love", list scent names such as "Raspberry Macaron" and call the markers "safe and nontoxic" for ages 3 and up. Nothing we found names the fragrance mixture, its allergens or what makes it smell like cake. So the seal can be checked and the scent cannot. Source (checked )

Brands in this guide

  • Crayola4 picks

Our top pick

Crayola Ultra Clean Washable Markers, 40 count, broad line, for ages 3 and up per the listing and Crayola's product pages. Why it leads: ACMI's register lists "Crayola Ultra Clean Washable Markers" with the AP seal (read in a browser 2026-11-15), Crayola's FAQ says its marker inks are "water and dye" and that "specific ingredient information is proprietary", and Crayola says the line washes from skin, washable clothing and most painted walls. The limits: the register row names the line, not this 40-count set by SKU; the dyes are not named; and washable is not the same as stain-proof, so check the label if the child is near a light sofa. On 2026-11-15 Amazon listed this set in stock from Amazon.com at $13.99, about 35 cents a marker. It is a pick on what we can check, not a safety ranking over the others.

Also worth considering

2

Crayola Color Wonder Marker Set, 32 count: the pick for a child who colors on the couch. Crayola's page says the markers "won't leave visible marks on skin, clothing, furniture" and the ink only shows on Color Wonder paper, and ACMI's register lists "Crayola Color Wonder Markers" with the AP seal. The catch is the paper: the markers do nothing on ordinary paper, so you buy refill pads too. It is graded 3+ like the others, so for a child who still mouths things follow the age grade; Crayola's page lists ages 3+ and Crayola's age FAQ also says it makes products "designed specifically for children ages 12 - 36 months", which is a separate toddler line we did not review. On 2026-11-15 Amazon listed the set in stock from Amazon.com at $17.99, about 56 cents a marker.

3

Crayola Pip Squeaks Washable Markers, 8 count mini markers: the small-hand set. ACMI's register lists "Crayola Pip-Squeaks Washable Markers" with the AP seal, and the listing says "specially formulated to wash from skin as well as most fabrics used in children's clothing" and "ages 3 & up". They are short, which suits a small grip and also means the cap is small; for under-threes the cap is a swallowing question, not an ink one (that is our reading, not Crayola's). On 2026-11-15 Amazon listed it in stock from a third-party seller, Homes Haven, at $5.85, about 73 cents a marker.

4

Crayola Silly Scents Washable Scented Markers, 10 count fine line: the scented pick, for a family that has decided on scented. ACMI's register lists "Crayola Silly Scents Washable Markers" with the AP seal, and the listing says ages 3 and up. What we could not find is what the scent is: Crayola's pages we read say "fun fragrances" and name flavors, and nothing about the fragrance mixture or allergens, and ACMI's own advice for a question like that is to contact the maker. Nothing we read says scented markers are unsafe for most children; the open question is fragrance sensitivity. On 2026-11-15 Amazon listed it in stock from a third-party seller, JJ Trading Inc, at $8.04, about 80 cents a marker.

What this page is for

"Non-toxic" is printed on almost every box of markers, and in the US it means less than it sounds like: every art material sold here has to be reviewed by a toxicologist and labeled under a federal standard, so the word does not separate one set from another. This page is for the parent choosing between the markers they already know and a scented or mess-free set. We looked at what a seal a parent can look up says, what each maker says about the ink, and what age the marker is made for.

If you want one set, Crayola's Ultra-Clean Washable Markers are the one we would buy: ACMI's register lists the line, Crayola says the ink is water and dye, and it costs about 35 cents a marker in the box we resolved. Nothing we read says washable markers are unsafe. Choose Color Wonder if the main worry is the couch: Crayola says it leaves no visible marks on skin, clothing or furniture. It is graded 3+ like the others. Treat scented sets as a separate decision with one thing we could not check.

What the AP seal covers, and what it does not

The seal to look for is the Art and Creative Materials Institute's AP (Approved Product) seal, and ACMI has a search tool where you can type a brand or product and see whether it is listed. We used it in a browser on 2026-11-15; it has a category for washable markers and a separate one for scented markers. ACMI says the seal means a board-certified toxicologist evaluated the formula for acute and chronic hazards, and that it is meant for products used by children in sixth grade or younger. ACMI is an association of art-supply makers, so this is an industry program, not a government approval, but it is still a toxicologist's review you can look up. It publishes no ingredient list. ACMI's own advice on whether a product contains a particular ingredient, such as a common allergen, is to contact the manufacturer.

"Conforms to ASTM D-4236" is a different, smaller thing. It is the labeling practice for chronic hazards in art materials: it decides whether a warning has to go on the box. CPSC's guidance says art materials have to go through a toxicological assessment at least every five years and carry a conformance statement where practicable, and that the federal art-materials rules are not a safety rule that requires certification. So a maker printing it is meeting the baseline, which is why it should not move your choice.

The ink: what makers say

Crayola is the only marker maker whose pages we read in full, so this is not a ranking of makers. Its FAQ says the "basic ingredients in Crayola® Markers are water and dye", that colors such as brown use several dyes and red only one, and that the specific formula is proprietary. That is a description of what kind of thing the ink is, and not a list of dyes. We did not find a children's marker maker that names its dyes, and we did not test any marker, so we cannot tell you how one brand's dyes compare with another's. What the seal and the maker's FAQ together give you is a reviewed formula and a statement of what it is made of in plain categories.

Scented markers and fragrance

Scented markers are the part of this page where we could check the least. ACMI lists scented markers in their own category, and Crayola's Silly Scents and Mr. Sketch's scented lines carry the AP seal, so the toxicological review covered them. But no maker we read says what the scent is. Crayola's pages say "fun fragrances" and list flavors such as mint chocolate chip and raspberry macaron. "Fun fragrances" is a category, not an ingredient list, and nothing we read says scented markers are unsafe for most children; the open question is fragrance sensitivity. Two things from ACMI are worth keeping. It says smell is not a good indicator of toxicity (a strong smell can be harmless and a sweet one is not a promise). And its answer for allergen questions is to ask the maker. If your child reacts to scented soaps or candles, the unscented set costs less and removes the question.

Under three, and over three

Every set on this page is graded 3+ by its maker or listing (Crayola's pages do not say why; small caps are our reading). Crayola also sells toddler lines we did not review. For a child who still mouths everything, the grade on the box matters more than the ink, and Color Wonder markers, which only show color on their own paper, take most of the mess out of the question. If your child is over three, the cards above say what each set does and does not tell you.

What we could not check

We did not test any marker. We did not find a children's marker maker that names its dyes. ACMI's register names lines, not the exact sets on Amazon by SKU. We did not read Newell's or Luxor's own pages for the ink or the scent, and we did not contact any company. A maker's page can lag its package, so the box in your hand wins.

The rest of the craft table

Markers sit next to the other things on that table that end up on small hands. Our non-toxic crayons guide covers what the wax is and which makers say so, the play dough showdown covers doughs that publish a recipe, and non-toxic slime and kinetic sand covers the sensory side of the table. The toys and art supplies cheat sheet is the short version, and the toys hub collects everything we cover for play.

What a marker box can say without telling you much

  • "Non-toxic" on the box — US law expects every art material to be reviewed by a toxicologist and labeled to ASTM D-4236, so "non-toxic" or "conforms to ASTM D-4236" is the baseline and cannot separate two brands. A maker that says what its ink is, or that sells a line ACMI lists, is telling you something more.
  • "Certified" with no name — ACMI's AP seal is the one you can look up. ACMI is an association whose members make art supplies, so the seal is an industry program's toxicological review, not a government approval. It is still a toxicologist's review you can verify, which a bare "non-toxic" is not. It does not name the dyes.
  • A seal that is not the AP seal — ACMI also has a CL seal, for materials with a health warning, meant for kids in seventh grade and up. ACMI says never give it to a child in sixth grade or younger, and that it appears on no children's materials; look for AP.
  • Permanent, dry-erase and fabric markers — ACMI lists permanent, dry-erase and fabric markers in separate categories. This page is about washable coloring markers for kids; a marker made to stay on skin, fabric or a whiteboard is a different material, so check the label for its own warning.
  • Face and body markers — ACMI's FAQ says art materials are expected to have only incidental or limited skin contact, and that products meant to be applied to the body, such as face paints and skin markers, fall under the FDA's cosmetic rules instead. A washable marker is not face paint.

How we choose

We looked at four checkable things: the product line appears in ACMI's register with the AP seal (searched in a browser on 2026-11-15), the maker's own pages say what the ink is, the maker states how it washes, and an age grade is printed. Passing them is a floor, not a ranking. Crayola passes the first and third; only its ink statement is thin, because it names a category (water and dye) and not the dyes. We did not find a maker of washable children's markers that names its dyes, so no marker here is a pick for transparency. Our one pick for most families is Ultra-Clean; if your child is under five and mess is the main worry, Color Wonder may fit better, though Crayola states no ink for it. We did not test any marker.

  • The product line appears in ACMI's certified-product search with the AP seal
  • The maker's own page says what the ink is (even if only as a category)
  • The maker states how the ink washes, and an age grade is printed
  • A purchasable Amazon listing resolved in stock on 2026-11-15, with the seller named
  • Preference, not a safety test: a mess-free marker (Color Wonder) if mess is the main worry

Every source we cite is checked against our criteria first — see how we check our sources.

What the research says

  • The CPSC this year issued 498 notices of violations for toys through June, as of the latest data available (Sept. 23, 2025).

    — A U.S. PIRG Education Fund report authored by Teresa Murray found ...

    Trouble in Toyland 2025: A.I. bots and toxics present hidden dangers — U.S. PIRG Education Fund (2025-11-13)

  • When you buy a toy or any other product online and it's shipped directly to you from another country, it generally doesn't get inspected before it gets to your mailbox.

    — A U.S. PIRG Education Fund report authored by Teresa Murray found ...

    Trouble in Toyland 2024: Unsafe toys that slip through the border — U.S. PIRG Education Fund (2024-11-19)

  • Selecting products labeled 'fragrance-free' rather than 'unscented' may help reduce exposure to endocrine-disrupting chemicals because unscented products may contain multiple scents, still bound by phthalates, that are mixed to cancel each other out.

    — According to American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists guidance co-authored by Tracey J. Woodruff, PhD, MPH, ...

    Reducing Prenatal Exposure to Toxic Environmental Agents (Committee Opinion No. 832) — American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists

Sources

  1. ACMI — Materials Safety (AP and CL seals, allergens, smell, skin contact) — Art and Creative Materials Institute
  2. ACMI — Certified Products Search Tool — Art and Creative Materials Institute
  3. ACMI — Regulations (ASTM D-4236 and the art-materials labeling law) — Art and Creative Materials Institute
  4. CPSC — Art Materials business guidance — U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (how we check this source)
  5. Crayola — What dyes are used in Crayola Markers? — Crayola
  6. Crayola — How do you manufacture Crayola Markers? (Canadian site) — Crayola
  7. Crayola — Are Crayola products nontoxic? — Crayola
  8. Crayola — Ultra-Clean Washable Markers, wedge tip, 8 count — Crayola
  9. Crayola — Color Wonder Marker Set, 32 count — Crayola
  10. Crayola — Silly Scents Smash Ups Fine Line Washable Markers — Crayola
  11. Crayola — At what age do you recommend children begin using Crayola products? — Crayola

Side by side

Comparison of 4 products
AttributeCrayolaUltra Clean Washable Markers 40ctCrayolaColor Wonder Marker Set 32ctCrayolaPip Squeaks Washable MarkersCrayolaSilly Scents Washable Scented Markers
Why it's hereOur top pick———
Price$13.99$17.99$5.85$8.04
AvailabilityIn stockIn stockIn stockIn stock

Common questions

Part of the Toys & Art Supplies hub— the rest of our coverage in this category.

Every toys & art suppliesproduct we've reviewed— what we'd buy, what we'd skip, and where each one stands.