Stores / Best stores for organic groceries
Best stores for organic groceries
Ranked by non-toxic catalog coverage first, then by trust/value/selection/shipping/service — from a store that bans 250+ ingredients across everything it sells to strong partial-organic grocers.
How this ranking works
Purity first, then score. A small store whose entire catalog is ingredient-screened outranks a bigger store with a higher score but an unscreened catalog — because how much of what a store sells has actually been vetted matters more than how good the shopping experience is around it. Every card below states which reason applies to it.
Why #1: Ranked #1 — a fully ingredient-screened catalog, plus the highest 3.0/5 average score among stores at that purity level.
The only grocery store here where the non-toxic standard covers the whole shelf — a store-wide 250+ ingredient ban applied to every vendor, not just house brand.
- Publishes a specific, checkable list of 250+ banned ingredients (artificial colors, flavors, sweeteners, hydrogenated oils) that applies store-wide to every vendor, not just house brand
- Requires vendors to complete an annual supplier agreement confirming certification and adherence to fair-labor and sustainable-palm-oil sourcing
Only 27 stores, all East Coast/Midwest — no ship-nationwide option if there's no location near you.
Why #2: Purity tier: a partly-screened catalog. 3.7/5 average score breaks the tie within that tier.
Partial: real organic/non-GMO curation and a B Corp record, but not a store-wide ingredient screen — broadest packaged-organic catalog of the group.
- Certified B Corporation with a public B Impact Score of 112.2, more than double the 50.9 median for ordinary businesses assessed
- Free shipping on grocery orders of $49+ (frozen orders need $99+), otherwise a flat $5.95/$19.95 fee — a published, checkable threshold
Membership fee is annual — worth it only if you clear about $49/month in orders.
Why #3: Purity tier: a partly-screened catalog. 3.3/5 average score breaks the tie within that tier.
Partial: bulk organic/non-GMO focus with unbeatable case pricing, if a drop point is within reach.
- Bulk-size staples (grains, beans, oils) at prices below typical retail organic grocery, since customers order case/bulk quantities directly from the distributor rather than a retail markup chain
- Runs an active affiliate/referral program that credits both the referrer and new customer toward future purchases
Drop-point pickup only in most regions — no doorstep delivery, and trucks typically visit monthly.
Why #4: Purity tier: a partly-screened catalog. 3.3/5 average score breaks the tie within that tier.
Partial: verified USDA organic handler certification, but only 50%+ of produce is organic by its own count.
- Its Arizona warehouse holds an active USDA National Organic Program handler certification through CCOF (certified March 10, 2025), verifiable on CCOF's own directory
- States more than 50% of its produce department is certified organic, on its own published sourcing page
Only about half the produce department is certified organic — check the label per item.
Why #5: Purity tier: a partly-screened catalog. 3.3/5 average score breaks the tie within that tier.
Partial: 'vast majority' organic produce, ships nationwide, ~30% below typical supermarket pricing.
- States the vast majority of its fresh produce is certified organic and non-GMO, and marks organic items clearly on the site so shoppers aren't guessing
- Produce boxes run roughly 30% below typical supermarket prices for organic/non-GMO produce, per its own published Mischief ($22 for 10-13 lb) and Madness ($35 for 18-22 lb) box pricing
Produce selection rotates and isn't shoppable item-by-item — you get what's in that week's box.